Well, seeing as you placed all of these titles here, they are Horror games (of course, except for Smallville). I don't have anything against these titles, but I don't like Horror movies/vid games. Now, I do know for a fact that that Jason & Freddy games were out for NES & maybe Sega by the same time the movies were coming out. Even though I don't watch much Horror movies, I did like Freddy vs Jason. In an order from the best to worst would be:
Smallville (since I like Superman)
Freddy vs. Jason (where you pick either one to play with)
Saw Trilogy (since the movies were recently made, but you play as a "made-up" cop)
Nightmare on Elm St. (already out, movie & game sucked)
Friday the 13th (must I repeat myself?)
The Shining (never seen it, so it might as a game)
Halloween (ditto)
Well, this would be my order & I put them from the coolest to the lamest. The first 3 I might invest my $ on if they were to come out, but the rest, NO WAY!! Although I didn't mention it on the list & you haven't thought bout it (shame, shame), I would like to play the game similar to Stayin Alive (but without the "Game Over" happening in real life). If you haven't seen this movie, check it out, cuz that a real good concept of a video game integrated into a Horror flick. Ok, that's enough from me, so see ya!