Game Recommendations?

Question

I like single-player games with good plots and gameplay, I usually prefer first person but it doesn't matter. I'd like some recommendations for Xbox 360 and PS3 games. I recently got GameFly and have access to a LOT of games so I'd like to start trying more.

These are some of my favorites:
(Then again, I don't think I can list any more than these, so it's more like a summary of all I've ever played)

Portal 2
BioShock
Fallout 3
Fable 1 and 2
Skyrim/Oblivion

PS2/PS1:
Kingdom Hearts series
Jak Trilogy
Ratchet Trilogy
Sly Trilogy
Spyro Trilogy (original)

And I also like games that are simply fun to mess around in, like GTA, but I'm looking more forward to playing games like those. I also have a pretty good PC and wouldn't mind trying PC games. I've played Runescape and WoW in the past, and they were good childhood games but I don't think I would be interested in games like that anymore.

(Note: I posted this already, but I don't think it was ever published)

Answer 1

Try Games Finder they have a page for most of the games you list: http://gameslikefinder.com/games-like-directory/



Some of my recommendations for you:

Assassin's Creed series

Saints Row series (since you mention liking GTA)

Metro series

STALKER (PC though)

Far Cry series

Mass Effect series

Answer 2

Everquest 2 is an amazing free online MMO

older Final Fatasy series has the best stories (buy on PSN cheap)

Heavy Rain

Alice: The Madness Returns

Assassins Creed has a great story line really in depth especially as Ezio

Dragon Age origions

Dragon Age 2

Any of the Batman Games

God Of War

Dante's Inferno

Mirror's Edge (Can't wait for part 2)

Infamous and ofcourse Infamous 2

Ilove all of these games check them out :D

Answer 3

Mass Effect and Fallout! You have to play those.